Skip to content

Sales commission structures, with worked examples

Flat rate, product rates, tiers, gross margin, splits, base plus commission and draws: one wholesale order worked through every structure.

By Cartwork ·

On this page
  1. The example order
  2. Step one: pick the base
  3. 1. Flat percentage of revenue
  4. 2. Different rates by product
  5. 3. Tiered rates: retroactive vs. marginal
  6. 4. Percentage of gross margin
  7. 5. Splits between two reps
  8. 6. Base salary plus commission
  9. 7. Draw against commission
  10. Which structure fits?
  11. Where Repvoy fits

The common sales commission structures are a flat percentage of revenue, different rates by product, tiered rates, a percentage of gross margin, splits between reps, base salary plus commission, and a draw against commission. The rate gets the attention, but the base often matters as much: the same 6% pays $54.00 or $61.02 on the same order depending on whether you count discounts, shipping and tax. Below, one hypothetical order is worked through every structure so you can compare them side by side.

The example order

Every number in this guide comes from one made-up wholesale order, #1001, placed by a rep for a gift shop. No real merchant or rep is involved.

Line Qty Price List total Cost per unit Total cost
Ceramic mug 40 $10.00 $400.00 $4.00 $160.00
Teapot 12 $30.00 $360.00 $13.00 $156.00
Tea tin 30 $8.00 $240.00 $3.00 $90.00
Subtotal $1,000.00 $406.00
  • Order discount: 10%, so $100.00 off. Net merchandise: $900.00.
  • Shipping: $45.00.
  • Sales tax: 8% on merchandise only (for simplicity), $72.00.
  • Total the buyer pays: $1,017.00.
  • Gross margin: $900.00 − $406.00 = $494.00 (54.9% of net sales).

Step one: pick the base

Before any structure, decide what the rate is applied to. Here is a flat 6% on four possible bases:

Base Amount Commission at 6%
List subtotal, before discount $1,000.00 $60.00
Net sales: after discount, before shipping and tax $900.00 $54.00
Net sales plus shipping $945.00 $56.70
Order total with shipping and tax $1,017.00 $61.02

Paying on the order total costs 13% more than paying on net sales ($61.02 vs. $54.00), and the extra is commission on tax you pass to the state and shipping you pay a carrier. Most plans use net sales: after discounts, before shipping and tax. Whatever you pick, write it down, because the rest of this guide assumes net sales.

1. Flat percentage of revenue

One rate on every sale: 6% × $900.00 = $54.00.

It’s easy to explain and easy to check, which is why most small wholesale teams start here. The weakness is that it treats a low-margin line and a high-margin line the same, and it doesn’t care how deep the rep discounted.

2. Different rates by product

Pay more on the lines you want to push. The 10% order discount is spread across the lines in proportion to their value, so each line is reduced by 10% before the rate applies:

Line Net after discount Rate Commission
Ceramic mug $360.00 6% $21.60
Teapot $324.00 4% $12.96
Tea tin $216.00 10% $21.60
Total $900.00 $56.16

Product or collection rates are a lighter-weight way to steer reps toward margin without sharing your costs with them. Decide what happens when a product has its own rate and also belongs to a collection with a different one, and write down which wins.

3. Tiered rates: retroactive vs. marginal

A tiered plan raises the rate as a rep’s sales for the period grow. Take these monthly tiers on net sales:

Monthly net sales Rate
Up to $10,000 5%
$10,000 to $20,000 7%
Over $20,000 9%

There are two ways to apply them, and they pay very different amounts:

  • Retroactive (whole-period): once the rep reaches a tier, the tier’s rate applies to all sales in the period.
  • Marginal (bracket): each tier’s rate applies only to the sales inside that bracket, like income tax brackets.

Say the rep had $9,500 of net sales this month before order #1001. The order brings the month to $10,400.

Before the order After the order What order #1001 added
Retroactive $9,500 × 5% = $475.00 $10,400 × 7% = $728.00 $253.00 (28% of the order)
Marginal $9,500 × 5% = $475.00 $500.00 + $400 × 7% = $528.00 $53.00 (5.9% of the order)

Retroactive tiers create a cliff. At $10,000 of sales a rep earns $500.00; at $10,001 they earn $700.07. That’s a strong push toward the threshold, and also a reason for reps to pull orders into the month or ask a customer to order early. Marginal tiers reward growth without the cliff.

Refunds hit retroactive tiers hard. If $500 of this month’s sales is refunded and the month falls back to $9,900, the retroactive commission drops from $728.00 to $495.00 (−$233.00). Under marginal tiers it drops from $528.00 to $495.00 (−$33.00). The clawback guide covers how to handle that.

For a full month the gap is larger. At $25,000 of sales, retroactive pays $25,000 × 9% = $2,250.00. Marginal pays $500.00 + $700.00 + $5,000 × 9% = $1,650.00.

4. Percentage of gross margin

Pay on what the order earns, not what it bills. At 12% of gross margin: 12% × $494.00 = $59.28.

The difference shows when a rep discounts. Suppose the rep gave 20% off instead of 10%: net sales fall to $800.00 and margin to $394.00 (the cost doesn’t change).

10% discount 20% discount Change
6% of revenue $54.00 $48.00 −$6.00 (−11%)
12% of gross margin $59.28 $47.28 −$12.00 (−20%)

On a margin plan, the extra discount costs the rep twice as much, so they think harder before giving it. The price is complexity: you need an accurate cost for every product, and reps need to see enough of it to trust their statement. Shopify lets you record a cost per item as part of product pricing, but the commission is only as good as those numbers. If you’d rather not share costs, product rates (structure 2) get you part of the way.

5. Splits between two reps

When two reps share an account, for example one who opened it and one who services it, split the base, not the commission, so each rep can keep their own rate. Here order #1001 is split 60/40:

Rep Share of net sales Rep’s rate Commission
Rep A 60% = $540.00 6% $32.40
Rep B 40% = $360.00 4% $14.40
Total $900.00 $46.80

If both reps were on 6%, the split would pay $32.40 and $21.60, the same $54.00 as one rep. Agree on the proportion per customer before the first order, and decide whether the split counts toward each rep’s tier at their share or in full.

A related case is the manager override: the rep’s manager earns a small rate on the team’s sales on top of the rep’s commission. A 1% override on order #1001 adds $9.00. Decide whether it goes to whoever manages the rep today or whoever did when the order was paid. For accounts that no rep should earn on, see house accounts.

6. Base salary plus commission

A fixed salary plus a lower rate. Compare $3,000 a month plus 3% of net sales with straight 6% commission:

Monthly net sales $3,000 + 3% Straight 6%
$40,000 $4,200.00 $2,400.00
$100,000 $6,000.00 $6,000.00
$150,000 $7,500.00 $9,000.00

On order #1001 alone, the base-plus plan pays $27.00 of commission. The two plans cost the same at $100,000 a month. Below that, the salary protects the rep; above it, straight commission pays more. Base-plus-commission suits in-house reps who also do account service. Straight commission is common with independent reps who carry several lines. The independent vs. in-house reps guide compares the two.

7. Draw against commission

A draw is an advance paid every period and settled against the commission the rep actually earns. It smooths income for a new rep or a seasonal business. Take a $2,000 monthly draw:

Month Commission earned Recoverable draw: paid Carried deficit Non-recoverable draw: paid
1 $1,400.00 $2,000.00 $600.00 $2,000.00
2 $2,900.00 $2,300.00 $0.00 $2,900.00
3 $2,500.00 $2,500.00 $0.00 $2,500.00
Total $6,800.00 $6,800.00 $7,400.00
  • Recoverable: the $600 shortfall in month 1 is taken out of month 2’s commission above the draw ($900 − $600 = $300 extra). Over time the rep receives exactly what they earned.
  • Non-recoverable: the shortfall is forgiven, so the draw works as a guaranteed minimum. It cost $600 more here.

Rules on recovering draws vary by place. New York’s Department of Labor, for example, says a draw can be recovered only if the written agreement says so and states how often it is reconciled (Payment of Commissions FAQ). Have a lawyer check your draw terms before you use them.

Which structure fits?

If you want to… Consider
Start simple with a small team Flat % of net sales
Push certain lines Product or collection rates
Reward growth without a cliff Marginal tiers
Stop reps from discounting away margin % of gross margin
Share accounts fairly Splits of the base
Hire reps who also service accounts Base plus commission
Support a new rep through ramp-up A draw, with written terms

Whichever you pick, put it in a written plan that states the base, the rates, and what happens on refunds. The sales commission plan template has every clause, and the guide to tracking commission on Shopify covers the monthly routine.

Where Repvoy fits

Repvoy calculates commission on paid Shopify B2B orders. It handles structures 1, 2, 3 and 5 from this guide, plus manager overrides:

  • A flat store rate, or rates per rep, customer, product or collection. For each line the first rate found applies: the product’s own rate, then the highest collection rate, then the customer’s, the rep’s and the store default.
  • You choose whether commission is calculated with or without tax, and with or without shipping.
  • Splits with a second rep, each earning their own rate on their share.
  • Monthly or quarterly sales tiers that work the retroactive way: an extra rate on all of the period’s sales, plus the tier’s bonus, recalculated when orders are paid or refunded.

Repvoy doesn’t calculate gross margin commission, salaries or draws. Those stay in payroll. The commission docs have the details.

Put your sales reps inside Shopify B2B

Start on the free plan with one rep. Upgrade when the team grows.